My boyfriend wanted to see me with another man, and I played along

My name is Mariana, I’m twenty-four years old, and I’ve been with Daniel for five years. I was never one to settle for a lukewarm relationship, and luckily he wasn’t either. We tried almost everything two people who desire each other can try, and still something new always came up. Daniel is one of those men who enjoy seeing me all done up, who buy me lingerie without my asking, who keep staring when I come out of the bathroom wrapped in a towel. And I love feeling desired. With him, I won the lottery.

That afternoon I was at my mother’s house, drinking mate in the patio, when my phone buzzed.

—Love —he texted.

—What’s up? —I replied.

—I started thinking and came up with a few ideas.

Here we go again.

—What’s gotten into your head now? —I asked him, already smiling to myself.

—I’ll tell you, and you tell me if you want to try them. At least once, to see if you like them.

—I always end up doing whatever you come up with —I wrote—. Come on, tell me.

—Don’t think I’m weird.

—You already are weird. That’s why I love you.

It took him a while to send the list. When it came, I read it twice.

—One: fuck in the street, in a square, at night. Two: you go out walking in lingerie, heels, and a collar, far from here. Three: a Bluetooth vibrator I control from my phone. Four: seeing you kiss and touch another man.

I stared at the screen. The first three I could picture; they were our kind of mischief. The fourth was something else.

—We can do the first one whenever you want. The second, at night and far away, maybe. The third, buy it already, you’ve been promising it for months. The fourth... are you sure about that?

—Completely sure —he answered right away—. I’ve been thinking about it for a while, I was kind of embarrassed to tell you.

—You, embarrassed? —I wrote—. Come on, we’ve already done worse things and your hand never even shook.

—It’s not the same. This isn’t normal.

—You’re not normal, my love, and that’s why I choose you. If you want to see me with another man, I’ll do it. But give me time to choose the right one.

—Take all the time you need.

—One thing —I added—. I don’t want you to regret it later or for this to cause problems between us. I’m crystal clear that I love you. If I do it, I do it for you.

—I know. That’s why I thought so much before telling you. I love you.

Honestly, I wasn’t that surprised. For a while Daniel had been dropping hints about a threesome, and he never dared ask me outright. I suspected this was his way of slowly starting to open that door.

***

Right there in my mom’s patio, I opened the chat. There was a guy who commented on every story I posted, who wrote to me every time I put up a photo. Tobías. I’d never paid him much attention; I’d never cheat on Daniel behind his back, because there’s no one like him. But this wasn’t behind his back. This was for him.

I posted a slightly explicit photo, one that left little to the imagination, and waited. I wasn’t going to text first; I wanted him to come on his own. Thirty minutes later, the message came in.

—Wow, you look gorgeous —he wrote.

—Thanks, baby.

—How I’d love to spank that ass.

—Come and do it —I replied.

—Seriously?

—I’m always serious.

—And your boyfriend?

—Are you going to hold back because of him?

—No, but I’m asking anyway.

—If you want to touch me, come to my place.

—Done. I’ll come by tonight.

I put the phone away with my pulse a little faster. Daniel was going to be speechless when he saw I was fulfilling his fantasy the very same day he asked for it. I spent the rest of the afternoon with my mother, and around five I went home, showered, and put on a lace set he’d given me.

—You’re way too gorgeous —he told me as soon as he saw me.

I kissed him and didn’t tell him anything yet. Some forty-five minutes later, Tobías let me know he was on his way.

—Love, I’ve got a surprise for you —I told Daniel.

—What is it?

—I’m going to fulfill one of your fantasies.

—Which one?

The doorbell rang before I could answer. I went to the door and opened it. Tobías came in with a nervous smile, not even trying to hide the way he looked me up and down. When he and Daniel met eyes, they both froze. Daniel fixed his gaze on me as if to say ah, that fantasy.

—Tobías, meet my boyfriend. Daniel, this is Tobías, the guy who came to spank me —I blurted out, laughing my ass off.

Tobías nearly had a heart attack. Daniel burst out laughing at my cruel joke.

—Relax, man, it’s all good. Make yourself at home —Daniel said, with a look of happiness that barely fit in his body.

—Thanks —Tobías muttered, still pale.

—See, idiot? My boyfriend isn’t saying anything. Relax —I insisted.

—I thought you were fucking around.

—I told you I’m always serious. Right, love?

—Right —Daniel answered.

***

Tobías sat down on the single armchair. Daniel settled onto the three-seater with his phone in hand, pretending to look at something. I sat on Tobías’s lap to ease his nerves, and we talked for a while about nothing in particular until the tension started to melt. Then I got up to bring him a glass of water. The kitchen is open to the living room, so they could see me perfectly.

Daniel came up behind me, smacked my ass, and whispered in my ear:

—I’m going to watch you on the camera.

We had a hidden camera in the living room, installed for security. He winked at me, headed down the hallway to the bedrooms, and before leaving he told Tobías:

—Don’t spank her too hard, yeah?

—Don’t worry —Tobías answered, laughing for the first time without tension.

I handed him the water and heard Daniel turn on the TV in the bedroom. A soccer match, just loud enough. With the coast clear, Tobías stood up, grabbed my waist, and bent me over the back of the armchair, leaving my ass in the air. And, against everything my boyfriend had asked, he started spanking me hard. I love it that way, the firmer the better. I moaned and laughed at the same time.

After a while he turned me around, set me on my feet, and kissed me while squeezing me with both hands. I felt his erection perfectly through his pants. I pushed him into the armchair, knelt down, and yanked his pants down. I pulled it out and started sucking him, making as much noise as I could. He rested his hand on the back of my neck, not forcing me, just letting himself go. I licked the sides, watching him while my tongue slapped against the head. When I felt he couldn’t take it anymore, I sped up until he came, thrusting all the way in. I swallowed everything, cleaned myself off, and tucked him back into his pants like nothing had happened.

That’s when Daniel appeared.

—I see you’re already done —he said.

—Yeah —Tobías replied—. Your girlfriend’s an expert.

—I trained her well —Daniel joked, and Tobías nearly had a heart attack again.

—Love, bring me some water, he almost drowned me —I said, and they both laughed.

—Whenever you want a blowjob, my girlfriend is at your disposal —Daniel kept going, amused.

—Seriously, man?

—Seriously. Right, love?

I was starting to like this game.

—Right —I said.

Tobías left, promising to come back the next day. Before leaving, I kissed him at the door, in front of Daniel, while Daniel squeezed my ass. As soon as the door closed, Daniel grabbed me, turned me around, and fucked me in one go. He fucked me hard, fast, holding me by the arms, until I ended up trembling and he came inside me.

—You liked what I did —I told him later, both of us sprawled on the bed.

—Too much. I was touching myself while watching you. I never thought you’d go for it so fast.

—I wasn’t planning to, but I knew you’d love it. What surprised me was your dominant act.

—Sorry, I got carried away.

—Don’t apologize. It turned me on so much the way you talked to him.

***

The next day, Tobías texted me from work saying he couldn’t wait to get out. That afternoon I put on a tiny dress, one of those that with two steps was already riding up and leaving half my ass exposed. Daniel loved it for exactly that reason, even though he almost never let me wear it out on the street.

When Tobías arrived, the three of us talked for a while in the living room. I sat on top of him and, after a bit, kissed him right there, in front of my boyfriend. I settled my legs around his sides and the dress climbed up to my waist. Tobías didn’t take even five seconds to slide his hands down to my ass. He kissed me, squeezed me, while I rubbed myself on him and Daniel watched from the couch with a smile that said it all.

I knelt down again, pulled down his pants, and sucked him with the same intensity as the night before. Daniel watched his girlfriend on her knees, gobbling up another man, and his face lit up. When Tobías finished, I wiped myself clean, stood up, went over to Daniel, pulled down his shorts, and did the same to him.

—God, she sucks incredible —he said—. See, man?

—An expert —Tobías answered.

Daniel didn’t last long and came too. After that I stood up, went to the kitchen with my dress still hitched up, and poured water for the three of us. When I came back, they were both talking in low voices, laughing about something I couldn’t make out.

—Well, I’m going to leave you, I’m going to shower —Daniel said suddenly.

He kissed me and gave me a smack before heading off. It seemed strange to me that he’d leave us alone right then, but I didn’t connect the dots. I didn’t realize Tobías was already hard again. He kissed me standing up, grabbing my ass, and with one move he put me on all fours on the couch. I thought he was going to spank me again. I was wrong. He moved the thong aside and shoved into me in one stroke. I moaned loudly, unable to hold back.

He grabbed my hips and started fucking me hard, giving it everything he had. The slap of flesh and my moans filled the living room. He whispered things in my ear, that he’d always come back, that he loved it. And I played along, lost in the thrill that Daniel might be watching from the other room. When he finished, I collapsed onto the couch, completely wrecked.

Daniel reappeared with a towel over his shoulder.

—You already gave her one, man? —he asked, as if nothing had happened.

—Yeah —Tobías laughed—. Look how I left her.

—You idiots —I said, lying there and smiling—. Pass me something to clean myself with.

Tobías got dressed, we kissed at the door, and he left. Daniel was so turned on that within just a few minutes he came again.

—You know Tobías is going to start coming over a lot now, right? —I told him.

—I know. And you love it.

—Obviously. But I like you.

—Soon we’re both going to give it to you —he said, hugging me.

—You’re going to kill me with pleasure.

—That’s the idea —he laughed—. I told him he could fuck you. That’s why he dared.

—No wonder he got so bold. And no wonder you left at such a perfect time —I shot back, giving him a little tap on the chest.

—I knew you wanted it.

—Honestly, I didn’t think about it. It caught me off guard. But I liked it.

—I love seeing you like this —he said, kissing my forehead.

—Only for you, my love —I answered.

And I curled up against him, knowing that the door we had opened was one we were never going to close again.