The Secret I Shared with My Two Siblings

My name is Daniela and, before you keep reading, I should warn you that my family isn’t like everyone else’s. I have three mothers and two brothers. Carla is my mother Beatriz’s daughter, and Nico is my mother Aurora’s son. I’m Renata’s daughter. My father, Esteban, built his life with the three women at once, and here we are, all living under the same roof like one big, happy family. Sounds weird, I know. There are people with far more tangled stories than ours.

I’m twenty-one, with tanned skin and hair somewhere between blonde and brown. Carla and I look so much alike that more than once we’ve been mistaken for twins, though she’s a couple of shades darker. We borrow each other’s clothes, shoes, everything. And Nico… Nico is identical to my father: tall, broad-shouldered, with that face that turns heads on the street.

We live in a big house on the outskirts of Nice, with a garden and a pool. At home, nudity was never taboo. We don’t go around naked all day, but nobody so much as blinks at seeing someone without clothes. In the pool we swim naked, unless there’s company.

I’m telling you this because a couple of years ago something happened that I didn’t understand at the time. Some friends from school invited me to the beach and I walked into Carla’s room without knocking.

—Sorry, Carla, I didn’t know… —I backed out, closing the door.

—It’s nothing, come in —she got up and came toward me—. Did you want to tell me something?

—I thought you were…

—I wasn’t touching myself —she cut in quickly—. I was just looking, because I need to shave again.

I would have sworn otherwise, but I didn’t press it. The next day we went to the beach, had a fantastic day, and the matter was buried. Or so I thought.

***

At the beginning of this year, something similar happened, but the other way around. I woke very early with my body on edge, with that feeling of wanting someone there, touching me everywhere. But I was alone. Just my body, my desire, and me.

One hand went up to my breasts, kneading them, pinching my nipples until they were hard. The other slipped down between my legs, where I was already wet. A finger traced the path from my clit to my opening and back again, over and over, raising the temperature. I brought my wet fingers to my mouth, sucked them, and lowered them again to sink two into myself. My hips moved on their own. I could feel an orgasm building deep inside, but I didn’t want it to end yet. I wanted to stretch the pleasure out.

Then something happened I hadn’t expected.

The door opened and Carla appeared. As soon as she saw the scene, she slammed it shut, and like a hunting cat she jumped onto my bed and pressed herself against my body under the sheets. One of her hands replaced mine. Two fingers slid into me while her mouth caught one of my nipples and sucked it slowly.

What is going on here? I thought, too weak to stop her.

My sister knew I was on the edge and worked even harder. I felt something growing at the small of my back, something bigger than any orgasm before. When it hit, I screamed so loudly that Carla let go of my nipple and sealed my mouth with hers to silence me. She didn’t let me rest: her fingers went back on the attack, her thumb grinding my clit, her tongue against mine. I wanted to stop, but my body was obeying only her. And then I noticed her sex rubbing hard against my thigh. We came together, wrapped around each other, and collapsed exhausted beside one another.

It took me a while to come back to reality. And when I did, I got scared.

—Carla, please get out of my room.

—Dani… forgive me, I…

—Go. Out of my room.

—Will you let me explain for a second?

—Not now.

She went into my bathroom, grabbed my shower gel, and left. I suppose that had been the original reason for her visit. My head was spinning. I couldn’t understand how she’d dared to take me like that, without asking. I’m no prude; I know perfectly well my mothers spend nights together. But why me? And why had I liked it so much?

***

I decided to take a shower to clear my head. Only I no longer had any gel… but I knew where there was some. I went to Nico’s bathroom and, oh surprise, he was showering.

—Hi, little brother, how’s it going?

—Good, and you? What do you want? Because “little brother” isn’t free.

—How clever. I came to borrow your gel, but you’re using it.

—No problem, come in. That way you can repay me and soap up my back.

It wasn’t the first time we’d seen each other naked, that had never been a problem between us. I lathered his back, those broad shoulders, that gym-built back. Everything was fine until my hands wandered down on their own.

—Just soap, Dani —he said without turning around—. Just soap.

—Let me enjoy something. I’m your sister.

What I was really trying to do was get Carla out of my head. But having Nico’s body in front of me was hardly helping me clear my mind.

—Done. Now it’s my turn —I said.

He ran the sponge over my back with massages that felt far too good. When he said he was done, I turned around.

—You missed the front.

—That’s not happening. I’m not soaping your breasts.

—As if this were the first time. Just soap, nothing else.

—Maybe… but last time you didn’t have these breasts.

—And you didn’t have this cock —I grabbed it and gave it a shake.

—Dani, what are you doing?

—Come on, let’s soap up the front, like we used to when we were kids.

Nico had always been shy, but he goes along with things. He started off tentative, slowly moving down my shoulders, until I took his hands and brought them to my breasts.

—If you’re going to do it, do it right. Don’t leave me halfway.

I kept going down his body while he busied himself with my breasts. I bent down to soap his legs and, when I straightened up, I teased him again.

—You’re missing something.

—Seriously? First you didn’t want to touch my breasts and now you want me to wash your cock.

—Come here, because you really are missing something.

—I’m kidding, Dani… seriously… don’t grab it, I can’t control it… please…

Nico’s cock started growing in my hand without stopping. Even I was surprised. Seeing him naked was normal, but having him hard between my fingers was another level. The arousal from before came back multiplied. With one hand I stroked that huge cock up and down while he massaged my breasts. I wasn’t washing him anymore: I was jerking him off properly. He brought one hand down to return the pleasure between my legs.

—This is a dangerous game, sister.

—Rub it against my pussy. Hard. Don’t think about anything else.

—It could slip inside…

—So? Do we do it or not?

He grabbed my hips and started moving as if he were truly fucking me. The head of his cock peeped teasingly at my entrance, parting my lips. He cupped my face and kissed me deeply just as he warned he was about to cum. I came with him, moving my hips to feel the tip barely entering me. I felt a hot spurt and, all at once, Nico pulled away and held me tight while we finished trembling.

—That was way too intense —he said afterward—. We’re siblings, Dani, we shouldn’t play like this.

—Really? You almost shoved your tongue down my throat and the tip inside, and now you’re making excuses? Don’t be stupid. We liked it. If it can be repeated, it gets repeated.

—I can’t deny it. I could hardly stand wanting to shove it all the way in.

—And I wanted you to. But it didn’t happen. Thanks for letting me borrow more than just the gel.

***

At noon we all had lunch together in a restaurant. Carla kept lowering her eyes every time she caught mine. I pulled her aside for a moment.

—Don’t hang your head. I want to apologize for what happened this morning. We’ll talk at home, okay?

—Okay, Dani —she answered in a trembling voice that wasn’t like hers at all.

Lunch dragged on. My parents had plans for the evening and Nico had a date with his girlfriend. Carla and I would be alone. When everyone left, I tied a towel around my body and went to her room. I didn’t want to put off the conversation anymore.

—Hi, are you busy?

—No, come in, I was waiting for you. Look, I…

—Shh, easy. I’m not here to blame you. I’m the one who should apologize for how I treated you.

—It hurt when you kicked me out… I thought I’d disappointed you.

—Not at all. I felt confused. Since when do you like girls? You never told me.

—It’s not that I like girls. I woke up horny, started touching myself, had a brutal orgasm and still wanted more. I went looking for your gel and found you just like me. My head exploded and what happened, happened. You were my first time.

—Wow, we woke up equally horny —I said, and hugged her to calm her down.

—I really am sorry. It won’t happen again.

—Do you really want it not to happen again?

We stared at each other and kissed, this time by mutual agreement. First soft kisses, just lips. Then our mouths opened and our tongues found each other. We fell together onto the bed. Carla threw my towel to the floor, I pulled off her T-shirt. We kneaded each other’s breasts, pinched each other’s nipples, I kissed her neck, went down her belly and took her nipples in my mouth.

I kept going down. I lifted her legs, pulled off her pajama shorts with my mouth and, when I came back up, a scent called to me. I opened her legs and went straight for her sex. Just putting my mouth there was enough to cut off her breath. When I caught her clit, she let out the air with a wet orgasm, pressing my head against her, her hips out of control. I slipped two fingers inside and fucked her with my mouth at the same time. She had a second orgasm, and a third left her begging me to stop.

She lay exhausted for a few minutes. I stretched out beside her, kissing her. But soon she recovered her strength, grabbed my face and kissed me like no one ever had. She climbed on top of me, went down to my breasts and one hand went straight to my pussy. Index and middle finger inside, thumb on my clit, ring finger playing with my slick asshole. She attacked me everywhere. I whispered that I was close and she kept going until I exploded.

She didn’t stop. She lowered her mouth to my sex while I was still trembling, her fingers went back inside, one slipping in from behind. I’m not multiorgasmic, but with that treatment I wasn’t going to last long. Then she sat facing me, lifted one leg and brought her sex against mine. We started rubbing together, moving like we were really fucking, because that’s what we were doing. We came at the same time, in a very long orgasm, and collapsed in defeat.

—For your first time, you left me in pieces —I said.

—You don’t look like a rookie either.

—You’re my first time too. I only do by instinct what I like having done to me.

Between kisses and caresses we fell asleep. Deeply asleep.

***

I dreamed someone was outside the room. They knocked on the door, once, then again. It wasn’t a dream. I opened it heavy-eyed and it was Nico, with a towel around his waist.

—Good morning, girls —he said as he came in—. What are you doing sleeping here, Dani?

—I had nightmares and came to Carla —I lied, going back to bed.

—Right. Well, I’m coming from your room and the bed’s perfect, nobody slept there. Here you’ve got the lock on the door, your towel and Carla’s clothes on the floor, the two of you naked… and it smells like sex. Are you two hooking up?

—No —I said.

—Yes —Carla blurted out at the same time.

—Then yes. I’m going, I’ll leave you in peace.

—Don’t go —I stopped him—. In this house we don’t keep secrets from each other, we’re not starting now.

—Then don’t judge —Carla said—, because you and I have a secret Dani deserves to know. Remember, two years ago, when you caught me touching myself and I denied it?

—Unforgettable.

—That morning I went to Nico’s room to get some notes and he was masturbating in the shower. I got undressed, went in, and we ended up jerking each other off.

—Well, well —I said—. That’s a lot like yesterday morning. When you walked out with my gel, I went for Nico’s while he was showering… and we shared more than just the soap.

—So you did it with both of them —Carla laughed—. You’re a little sneak. And what’s that lump under the towel, brother?

—I… nothing, it’s nothing —he said, covering himself with his hands.

—You’ve got an erection in front of your sisters —I said—. He admitted it yesterday: what’s bothering him is what we didn’t do, because the tip did get inside.

—I want some of that too —Carla said.

As if we’d planned it, the two of us jumped on Nico and ripped off his towel. We ran our tongues over his cock and licked each other. He grabbed Carla and buried his face between her legs until he drove her insane, while I devoured him. When he tried to sit up, I shoved him back down and climbed on top, rubbing my sex against his hard cock.

—Brother, we were regretting what we didn’t do, weren’t we?

—What are you plotting, Dani?

—I don’t want to regret it again.

Without giving him time, looking into those blue eyes just like Dad’s, I grabbed his cock and lined it up at my entrance. I sat down slowly, feeling him open me centimeter by centimeter, until my ass touched his body. I had to wait for my body to get used to the invader.

—It feels so good having you all the way inside —I panted.

—Dani, what have you done?

—I told you already: I’m not going to regret it again. You wanted this too.

I started moving in circles, riding him, while Carla sucked my breasts and pawed at me all over. Every thrust from Nico hit me deep. After a while he put me on all fours and entered me again, this time in one hard shove, all the way in. The howl I let out was silenced by Carla’s mouth, as she positioned herself in front with her legs spread, begging me to lick her. Nico fucked me like he was making up for lost time, his balls slapping against my ass, until he tore a brutal orgasm from me.

They switched places. Carla got on all fours and he entered her slowly, letting her feel him. I kissed her face, her neck, her breasts, while she breathed hard.

—Fuck me, brother, fuck me hard —Carla begged—. Give me more, more…

Nico laid her on her back, pulled her legs back until they were by her ears and gave it to her mercilessly. Carla went into a chain of orgasms. When he warned he was about to cum, she wrapped him up with her legs.

—Cum inside, fill me… knock up your sister —she blurted.

—What? No… let go… let go! —Nico broke free in time and started cumming outside.

I took the chance to grab his cock and let him shoot everywhere: in my hair, on my face, on my breasts. Carla was dying laughing and Nico looked at us sternly.

—Are you crazy? What do you mean, knock you up?

—It was to keep you going —she laughed—. I’m on the pill, idiot.

—I’m careful too —I added—. You’re the crazy one if you thought we’d risk it. You’re gorgeous, brother, but innocent.

—Come here so I can get rid of your scare —I told him.

Like a zombie, Nico came back to bed. I brought his hardness back with my mouth, climbed over Carla and signaled to my brother. He had two hungry sexies in front of him. He entered me first, that powerful cock forcing its way in, and Carla held my face, kissing me, while Nico set a steady rhythm. Then he started his favorite game: one thrust into her, one into me. One inside Carla, one inside me. The sensation was indescribable.

—You wanted brother cum —he panted faster—. Here it comes.

He filled us both, a little in Carla, a little in me, never stopping his motion. I won’t lie: it was the best fucking of our lives.

Nico left for his date. We asked him to tell everyone at home that we spent the night studying. Carla and I stayed in bed, still breathless. Last night I had my first time with my sister and today with my brother.

What will come now?