Noelia’s Sister and the Blindfold Game

It was Saturday and none of us was in a hurry to get up, even less after the night we’d had. I woke wedged between Lorena and Sofía, and it took some doing to slide out of bed without waking them. I left them naked, tangled in the sheets, and went to the kitchen quietly.

I’d forgotten my phone on the counter the night before. I had a string of messages from Bruno, each one more impatient than the last.

“What a lively night! Noelia told me you had company. It really shows it’s the weekend, lazybones. Are you that wiped out? I’ve got fresh croissants for breakfast.”

I laughed to myself as I switched on the coffee maker and replied.

—Morning, pest. I’ve just gotten up. The two of them are still in bed. Bring those croissants over, I’m making coffee.

I hadn’t finished typing when the doorbell rang. There was Bruno, grinning from ear to ear and holding a paper bag.

—Come on, I’m bringing you fuel so you can recover your strength —he said, walking in without waiting to be invited.

—They look great. And Noelia?

—She’s gone to pick up her sister at the station. She called last night and she’s spending the weekend with us.

—Then you’d better behave yourself these days —I teased.

—You’re going to freak out over the sister —he replied, and refused to say another word no matter how much I pressed him.

***

I didn’t get a chance to answer because the two of them appeared in the kitchen. Lorena had put on a short robe that barely covered anything, and Sofía was wearing a thin T-shirt that showed off her breasts shamelessly. Bruno stared at them, and though he didn’t know Sofía in person, he couldn’t keep his mouth shut.

—Jesus Christ! And you wake up that beautiful? A man’s only human.

Lorena burst out laughing and went over to greet him with a kiss on the cheek.

—You must be Bruno —Sofía said, holding out her hand.

—And you’re Sofía. I’ve heard a lot about you.

—I hope good things.

—More than good, trust me.

He told them about the sister and, just like me, none of us managed to get a single detail out of him. Besides breakfast, he’d come to invite us over for lunch at his place.

—Then I suppose we’ll have to get dressed —I said.

—It’s still early —he replied.

—But we have to get ready, do our makeup… —Lorena protested.

—You don’t need much touch-up —Bruno said, looking at Sofía, who was just finishing dunking a croissant in her coffee.

—I’m going to need a while. I’ve got to shower too.

—If you need help, I volunteer —he said brazenly.

—Volunteer, my ass. Go home, because with you around we’d be eating dinner —Lorena said, laughing as she chased him off.

Bruno left amid laughter while Sofía watched him go.

—I wouldn’t have minded if he’d rubbed my back —she murmured.

—I’m sure he was thinking exactly about your back —I told her, grabbing her from behind and lifting her from the chair—. Come on, I’ll rub your back.

Unfortunately, I was banished to the small bathroom while they locked themselves away to get ready for what felt like an eternity.

***

A while later Bruno came back, all dressed up, to say that Noelia and her sister were at the house finishing getting ready. We stayed in the living room until the two of them came out, and he was left speechless, which was rare for him.

Lorena had gone for tight white jeans, a black top that barely contained her breasts, and a blazer in the same color. Sofía wore blue jeans and a pale blouse that hinted at everything underneath. Both on heels.

—Jesus, I’m going to have a heart attack. What two stunners! —Bruno blurted out.

—Shut up, you bastard, with the bombshell you’ve got at home —Lorena chided him.

—Looking at the menu isn’t a sin.

There was a knock at the door, and when we opened it I was left speechless. For a moment I thought it was Noelia, that she’d dyed her hair, but all it took was dropping my gaze to realize it wasn’t her. The same curly mane, now a deep red; the same green, smiling eyes; a little shorter and with more curves.

She was wearing black pants and a black leather jacket over a printed top that strained over breasts determined to break free, and a tattoo climbed up between them.

—Hi. I’m Romina, Noelia’s little sister —she said, stepping inside.

I invited her in and couldn’t help noticing her round ass, identical to her sister’s. She went straight to hug and kiss Bruno.

—Hot brother-in-law! God, you look good.

—Hello, little whirlwind —he replied, and then introduced us—. These are Lorena and Sofía.

The three of them sized each other up before exchanging two kisses.

—My sister was right. You’re really pretty. And you must be Daniel —she said to me, giving me two kisses while pressing her breasts against mine.

Just then Noelia arrived, spectacular as always.

—I see you’ve already met my sister, the family’s black sheep.

—Shut up, little nun —Romina shot back.

***

After a while talking, we headed to the restaurant, a couple of streets away. The two sisters walked ahead, arm in arm, talking softly, and I admired their hips from behind while the others bantered.

We ate amid teasing and a friendly competition between brothers-in-law and sisters that little by little drew all of us in. Once the coffee came, Romina was the first to fire.

—Well. My sister’s already told me how much fun you have.

—Took you long enough —Noelia replied.

—She even showed me a video. Of Lorena and her.

Lorena didn’t hold back one bit.

—Then have her show you more. Of the two of us with Bruno.

—Shit, brother-in-law, from zero to a hundred —Romina laughed.

—And you’re jealous, as always —Noelia jabbed—. You even got breast implants to make them bigger than mine.

Romina grabbed her breasts with both hands.

—I paid for these with my own money.

We laughed until we were done. It was too early to go have a drink out, so we decided to go back to the house. On the way my imagination was already far ahead, and I’ll admit I was eager to get there.

***

We fixed some drinks and spread out around the living room. I ended up with Lorena and Noelia at my sides; Bruno, surrounded by Sofía and Romina. The conversation quickly turned to the way we understood relationships.

—I’m surprised by my sister, though I shouldn’t be —Romina said—. When she confessed that she liked girls too, I knew she wasn’t such a goody-two-shoes anymore. But from there to swapping partners…

—And right away you said you were bisexual too. Jealous much —Noelia laughed.

Surrounded by those four women, keeping his composure was difficult, for Bruno as much as for me. And if you added the fact that Lorena had been stroking my crotch over my pants for a while, my erection didn’t take long to give me away.

—What’s wrong, baby? —she asked with an innocent smile.

Noelia looked and burst out laughing.

—Well, look at my husband. And nobody’s even touching him.

Bruno had a solid bulge showing, and Sofía didn’t take long to slide her hand over it.

—I propose a game —Noelia said.

—Blindfold the two of them, so they don’t know who’s touching them —Romina added.

Bruno and I looked at each other, smiling. We agreed without thinking twice. While Noelia went to get some scarves, we stood up.

***

Once blindfolded, I felt hands tracing my abdomen and sliding down to my pants. With a tug they pulled them down and my erection sprang free. It wasn’t long before they had me completely naked. Then some hands took mine behind my back and I heard the metallic click of handcuffs closing around my wrists.

—You’re going to love it —Lorena’s voice said beside me.

But I couldn’t tell whether she was the one touching me or one of the other three. A mouth came to my cock and licked it slowly, and almost at once another joined in. Two tongues played with me at the same time and I, with my hands tied, could do nothing but feel. Beside me I started hearing Bruno’s muffled moans: he was getting the same treatment.

Hands pushed me until I was sitting on the sofa and a body settled between my legs. The warmth and wetness of lips enveloped me while a tongue circled the glans. Then a breast pressed against my face. I searched for the nipple blind, found it with my tongue, and caught it between my lips, unable to guess whose it was, not even from the panting right by my ear.

They made me stand up and lie down on the floor. A hand guided my cock and I felt someone sitting on top of me, easing it into her little by little, hot and tight. She started riding me gently, up and down. Since the handcuffs were digging into my back, they loosened them for a moment, pulled my arms over my head, and fastened them again in front.

I could only hear sighs around me when another body sat on my face. I stuck out my tongue and slid it from bottom to top, tasting the wetness, then buried myself searching for the clit. I found it, hard and swollen, and when I ran my tongue over it I drew a spasm and a moan from the woman on top of me. From that moan I knew it was Noelia. I tried to bring my hands to her body, but she held them with hers.

The other one was still riding me, and I recognized Lorena by the way she breathed, closer than the rest. I started lifting my hips, driving deeper and deeper, until I felt her spasms tightening around me: she’d come. She leaned over me to kiss me just as Noelia sat up.

***

They made me kneel. One of them positioned herself in front while the other guided my cock to her entrance, taking it in with a single movement. I stayed still and she was the one who started moving, impaling herself, while the other held my hands so I wouldn’t touch her.

Nearby I could hear the murmur of the others when, to my surprise, I felt Bruno’s cock brushing my face. With my mouth open I circled it with my lips and ran my tongue over the wet glans. The woman in front of me sped up as I tasted him, imagining that he too was blindfolded and didn’t know whose tongue was tending him, which made everything more intense.

Then hands spread my ass cheeks and a tongue slipped over my opening, circling it and wetting it. Minutes later Bruno disappeared from in front of me and I felt his cock pressing against me. Little by little he went inside while I held my breath, first the glans and then the rest.

So, while I sank into the sex in front of me, Bruno was thrusting into me without knowing it was me, and a new body offered itself to my mouth with each stroke. I heard him grunting behind me with every thrust. Just as I was about to come, I felt the woman I was fucking dismount, slide underneath, and take me between her lips, where I finished. Bruno kept driving until he came with a groan, filling me, before pulling out.

We both stayed on the floor, still blindfolded and cuffed, breathing hard.

***

Female hands helped me to my feet and led me to the shower, where two of them cleaned me from top to bottom. They dried me off and took me back to the sofa, where Bruno took my place under the water. When they came back, they sat him beside me.

—We thought we’d keep you like this all afternoon. We’ll see what we do with you —Sofía said.

—You’re not moving from there for anything. And you’re not taking off the scarves —Noelia added.

—No matter what you hear —Lorena finished.

—If you move, there’ll be punishment —Romina warned.

For a while all we heard were footsteps around the living room, until the kisses and soft moans began. The sofa sagged beside me when a body dropped onto it. A leg rested on mine. I made as if to touch it and a hand knocked mine away.

—Like that. Yes. Keep going, don’t stop —a husky voice whispered between gasps. Then it came close to my ear—. Mmm, your wife licks me so well. Almost as well as you do.

A hand turned my face and a mouth sought mine, sliding in its tongue while I answered. By the voice it could only be Romina, and at that very moment she grabbed my cock, firm, without moving it.

—Seriously… she’s going to make me come in her mouth. Fuck —she gasped against my lips.

When she came she kissed me again hungrily, and I felt her gasps fading little by little.

—Now I’m going to do that to her —she said, and got up.

***

Lorena’s body took her place. She rested her leg over mine and immediately started moaning. Unlike Romina, she took one of my hands to her breasts, which I recognized at once, so I could squeeze and pinch her hard nipples. Another hand, I suppose Romina’s, kept holding my cock.

—You do it really well too. What a pleasure. Don’t stop —Lorena panted, until, amid spasms, she came and collapsed against me.

Romina sat up, pressing her body against Lorena’s, and my hand was trapped between the two of them. I took the chance to grab a breast: it fit exactly in my palm, firm, with the nipple digging into me.

—Your wife has given me a lot of pleasure —Romina said hoarsely—. Now it’s your turn.

They lifted me off the sofa. Right there, standing, she positioned herself in front while Lorena guided my cock to her entrance. They let go of my hands and I was able to grab her hips and drive into her in one thrust, all the way in.

—Yes! I’ve wanted this so much —she moaned.

I started thrusting faster and faster and hands took off my blindfold. For the first time I could see her: her heart-shaped ass, her muscular back covered in tattoos that climbed from her waist to her shoulders, her face turned toward me.

—More. Give me more —she pleaded.

I kept going, paying no attention to anything else, until Sofía appeared, grabbed one of Romina’s breasts and kissed me on the mouth. Then she sat down in front, opened her legs, and Romina started licking her while I kept thrusting. I was so turned on I had to slow down to hold out, wanting her to come first. It didn’t take long, between moans, and then I sped up.

—Wait. Don’t come —she asked.

She turned, knelt down, and took me into her mouth, where I finished while it spilled from the corners of her lips. Afterward she grabbed my head and gave me a long, deep kiss, sharing what was left on her tongue.

***

Only then did I notice Lorena riding Bruno, who still had his eyes blindfolded but his hands free, gripping her breasts, while Noelia licked his cock, kneeling between his legs. The three of us stayed seated, watching them, until they finished and slumped down to rest.

—Fuck, that’s so hot, not knowing who you’re with —Bruno said, still breathless.

Romina and Noelia looked at each other, smiling.

—It leaves room for the imagination —Noelia replied.

—Could’ve been me. Or Sofía. Or Daniel —Lorena said flatly.

—Bullshit. I would’ve noticed —Bruno shot back.

He knew about my escapades with men, but he had no idea that the cock he’d felt behind him during the game had been me fucking him and him fucking me.

—You can watch it later. It’s all recorded —Lorena said.

I swallowed and looked at Noelia, who shook her head, amused.

—Romina’s idea —Sofía confessed.

—Fuck, sister-in-law. I had no idea you were like this —Bruno laughed.

—As if my sister and you don’t do threesomes. And now swaps —she replied.

We kept talking until dinner time, which we ordered in so we wouldn’t have to go out. The night, without a doubt, promised plenty.