The Gym Newbies Wanted to Try Something More

Over dinner I told Lucía how I’d spent the day while she was at work.

—So while I was busting my ass in the office, you were taking care of Nadia’s little ass —she said, raising an eyebrow over her glass.

—Something like that —I admitted.

—How they go for older guys. Or rather, how they go for mine.

I burst out laughing. She got up from the table and came around the chair to stand beside me, wearing that smile I knew far too well.

—And how are you going to make it up to me? —she asked.

I grabbed her by the waist and pulled her to me without getting up. I ducked my head under her T-shirt until I reached her bare breasts and ran my tongue over the nipples, which were already starting to harden.

—Like this? —I murmured against her skin.

—Mmm. That’s all?

I buried my face between her breasts, tickling her with my beard and going back to her nipples. I love it when they harden between my lips, feeling her hold her breath every time I nip at them. Lucía pressed my head against her until, impatient, she yanked her shirt off in one pull.

—That’s easier.

I kept licking them while one of my hands slipped under the waistband of her pajama bottoms and reached her sex. She was hot and wet. I brushed her clit and she shivered with a soft gasp.

—That story got you that worked up? —I asked.

—You know it.

I pulled down her pants and left her naked before my eyes, which never get tired of looking at her. She slid a hand down to my cock, already hard beneath the fabric.

—And from what I can tell, you too —she said.

—With you, always.

I stood up and held her. She wrapped her arms around my neck and kissed me while my erection pressed against her belly. I took her by the hips and sat her on the kitchen table. I went down kissing her neck, her breasts, her stomach, until I buried my tongue in her shaved pussy, searching for her clit. She was moaning, holding my head, and swinging her legs up over my shoulders.

—Mmm. I love it! Did you do that to her too? —she asked between gasps.

I didn’t answer. I was too busy sliding my tongue along her pussy, enjoying her scent and her taste. She had gotten so hot that it didn’t take long for her to start writhing. She threw her head back, breathing hard, her body convulsing.

—Fuck! I’m coming!

I didn’t stop for a good while. Then I straightened up, grabbed my cock, and shoved it in with one thrust. With her sitting on the table, legs around me, I started fucking her while I caressed her breasts.

—Yes! Fuck me! I love it!

A moment later I turned her over, braced her arms on the table, and went into her from behind again. There, holding her by the hips, I kept pumping while she panted and murmured words I couldn’t make out. I grabbed her hair and pulled carefully, lifting her head, and gave her ass a slap that echoed through the whole kitchen. She was breathing with her mouth open, beside herself.

There came a moment when she started having spasms. I could feel the muscles of her pussy contracting with every thrust, squeezing my cock as if they wanted to milk it. Not at all quietly, she had another orgasm without me slowing down.

When she relaxed, we stayed like that for a moment. I still wasn’t done.

—Now my ass —she said—. Like Nadia’s.

I didn’t hesitate. I pulled out of her pussy and rested the head of my cock against her anus, pushing slowly until I sank all the way in. I held her breasts from above and finished going in while she moaned.

—Yes! That’s it! Don’t stop!

I moved hard until I couldn’t hold back anymore and came inside her. I lay over her back for a moment, the two of us catching our breath. When we broke apart, Lucía turned around and rested her head on my chest.

—Mmm. So good.

We cleaned up the kitchen, took a shower, and got into bed, falling asleep instantly.

***

Days passed normally for a couple of weeks. Between work, the gym, and routine, we didn’t bring up the swap again. We kept training with Marcos and Nadia, but neither of them mentioned that first night, until one day, while the four of us were having a drink after training, he brought it up.

—You know that since that day with you, we haven’t done anything like that again? —Marcos said—. We looked into one of those places, but we don’t trust them.

—Are you ready for that yet? It’s a big leap —Lucía replied.

—What if you start with something at home? With people you know —I suggested—. We can set something up.

—Really? You don’t mind? —Nadia asked, eyes wide behind her glasses.

—As you can see, no —my wife smiled—. Besides, I’d be delighted to do it again with you.

It was obvious Marcos had no idea I’d been with his girlfriend again, and I left it at that. We kept talking and agreed we’d bring it up with some trusted friends, to see if they were interested.

***

Lucía and I were thinking of Bruno and Vanesa, our neighbors, and we didn’t hesitate to suggest it as soon as we got home. We rang their bell, Bruno opened up, and we asked them to come over for a drink. Five minutes later they were sitting in our kitchen.

—Is she the little bespectacled girl I saw you with in the garage? —Vanesa asked.

—That’s the one —I said.

Smiling, she looked at her husband.

—Then you’re going to like her. I’m telling you now.

Lucía described Marcos, stressing how inexperienced the two of them were —they’d only done it with us— and, of course, his big cock.

—Fine by me —said Bruno.

—And by me too —Vanesa added—. We’ll have a dinner and get to know them that way.

—And why wait? —I cut in—. I’ll call them right now, and if they’re free, they can come to dinner tonight.

The four of us agreed. I called Marcos, invited him to dinner, and told him we had a surprise. He had to check with Nadia, but five minutes later he called back to confirm. I told them to come around seven so we could have a drink first.

Vanesa and Lucía got busy organizing things, and we decided to order dinner from a nearby restaurant. The two of them went off to get ready for what promised to be a long night. Meanwhile, Bruno and I planned how to do it and came up with a game. The two of them would wait at their place until we called them.

Bruno left to tell Vanesa, and I did the same with Lucía. While she showered, I talked to her from outside, restraining myself from getting under the water with her. She thought it was perfect.

—It’s going to be fun. If they want to keep going, of course —she said.

—I don’t doubt it. I think they do want to try.

***

When Marcos and Nadia arrived, we greeted each other with kisses. She kissed me on the mouth, while he got his from Lucía. Seated in the living room with a drink in hand, we asked them whether they still wanted to go further.

—Yes, of course —Nadia replied—. We’ve already talked about it. But it has to be someone you know, people you trust.

—They are —I said.

—In fact, they’re our neighbors —Lucía added—. They’re coming to dinner later too, but we wanted to talk it over with you first. For now, just dinner. Then… we’ll see.

—Well then, it’s settled. We’ll eat and see what happens.

Nadia looked a little nervous, so I thought I’d start the game.

—What do you think about warming up a little first? —I suggested.

—What are you thinking? —Marcos asked.

—For example —Lucía said—: you sit in a chair with your eyes covered and we touch you so you can guess who it is. Then it’s Nadia’s turn, and we keep switching. I can start.

—Okay. Sounds fun —Nadia agreed.

I pulled up a chair and Lucía sat down without taking her clothes off. I already had a scarf ready, and she tied it around her eyes.

—The idea is not to talk, so you can’t recognize the voice —she warned.

I signaled to Nadia to go first. She stood in front of Lucía and, slowly, brought her head close to her neck and kissed it gently.

—Mmm. That delicacy… Nadia —Lucía guessed.

Nadia laughed. Next was Marcos, who reached out from the side and caressed one of her breasts over her blouse.

—By how much his hand is trembling, it’s Marcos —Lucía said with a laugh.

I motioned to Nadia again. This time she undid the buttons of the blouse, baring Lucía’s breasts —she wasn’t wearing a bra— and kissed her on the lips. Lucía responded by opening her mouth and kissing back.

—Nadia —she murmured.

I was next. I knelt down and kissed one of her nipples, sucking it between my lips.

—Mmm. Daniel, without a doubt.

Marcos brought his mouth close and, like his girlfriend had done before, kissed her neck while one hand gripped one of her breasts. Lucía was already breathing hard and took a moment before answering.

—Marcos… I think.

I came closer, slipped one leg between hers to spread them, and slid a hand down to her sex. She was wet with arousal, and she moaned my name. Nadia finished taking off her blouse and skirt, leaving her naked. Lucía remained seated on the chair, blindfolded, with me in front and the others at either side.

My hand gave way to Nadia’s, and she leaned in and started kissing her. Marcos made a move to undress, but I shook my head just as his girlfriend knelt between Lucía’s legs, opening them even wider. Her shaved pussy glistened with wetness while Nadia’s fingers kept playing with it.

Lucía moaned softly, repeating Nadia’s name, while Marcos and I kissed her breasts. Nadia, smiling, looked at her boyfriend before bending down and kissing the inner part of Lucía’s thighs. She immediately placed her tongue on her lips and, parting them, ran it from bottom to top in a single stroke. Lucía jerked and gasped.

—Nadia. Mmm.

Things were heating up by the minute. I could feel Marcos getting uncomfortable, his erection showing beneath his pants, just like mine. I started taking my clothes off and, as soon as he noticed, he did the same. While Nadia stayed between my wife’s legs, we took our places on each side and brought our cocks to her face.

It was Marcos’s cock that got Lucía’s attention first. I watched her open her lips and stick out the pink tip of her tongue to rest it on the head and slide it around it. She lifted her hands, grabbed both cocks, and set herself to licking the tips, murmuring our names. Then it was my turn: she took my whole cock into her mouth, licking it from top to bottom.

Nadia was the only one still dressed, and she kept drawing moans from Lucía while Lucía herself didn’t stop moving. She didn’t last long like that: with Marcos’s cock between her lips, she had the first of many orgasms that night. She stayed seated in the chair, catching her breath, while Nadia climbed up kissing her body until she reached her face.

***

Lucía got up with trembling legs and pushed Marcos toward the chair.

—Your turn.

She tied the scarf over his eyes and stood behind him, reaching her arms over his shoulders until she got to his nipples. She started pinching them gently while kissing his neck. I stood behind Nadia and, without her stopping looking at her boyfriend, slid my hands under her sweater to her breasts. Her nipples were hard and she moaned at my touch.

One of my hands went down over her belly, slipped under her pants, and, moving aside the waistband of her thong, reached her sex. She couldn’t have been wetter or hotter when I slid one finger up and down. Nadia leaned back against me, letting me handle her, while my finger sank into her and the other hand held her breast.

Behind us, Lucía kept stroking Marcos, running her hands over his belly until she grabbed his cock. He was panting, clinging to the sides of the chair, while I finished undressing his girlfriend. I took off her sweater and kissed her neck from behind before undoing her pants. While I did it, she had reached a hand back and was gently jerking me off.

It didn’t take long before she was down to her thong, which I also took off. I pulled her ass cheeks apart to see her sex from behind and, above all, her anus, which I brought my tongue to. She shivered when she felt it, along with my fingers brushing the entrance to her pussy.

By then, Lucía had already knelt in front of Marcos and was licking his cock eagerly. Kneeling like that, she showed us her ass, and Nadia soon got behind her. She gave her a slap, slid a hand between her legs, and Lucía responded by opening them even wider. We formed a chain: me licking Nadia’s anus, her licking my wife’s, and Lucía sucking Marcos’s cock, still blindfolded and oblivious to everything.

I went to get lubricant and spread it between my cock and Nadia’s ass. She didn’t move or stop licking Lucía while I slipped in one finger, and then another. When she was ready, I brought the head of my cock to her anus and started to enter very slowly. It was she who suddenly threw her ass back, impaling herself in one go with a long moan, and began to move.

Meanwhile, Lucía straightened up, straddled Marcos, and, gripping his cock, lowered herself little by little until she sank it into her own ass. She started riding him. I could see her breasts trembling until Marcos reached out and held them, while I fucked his girlfriend. She herself brought a hand between her legs and started rubbing her clit.

—Yes! Keep going! Harder! —Nadia screamed.

Above the moans, you could hear my body slamming against hers. She panted faster and faster until she started trembling under me.

—I’m coming! I can’t hold on any longer!

I felt her contractions squeezing my cock, and that was enough to make me come too without pulling out of her. I lay over her back for a moment, watching Marcos’s cock go in and out of my wife’s ass, until she came too. He held on a little longer, and Lucía, sensing it was close, moved faster until she took his release inside her.

None of the four of us could speak. The silence was broken only by the sound of our breathing.

***

I was the first to get up and dress just enough, and good thing too, because just then the doorbell rang. It was dinner, which we had practically forgotten about, along with warning Bruno and Vanesa. Though that last part was no longer necessary: the two of them showed up before I could close the door.

We found the living room empty. We left the things in the kitchen, and after a while, Lucía and Nadia came out of the bedroom dressed as if nothing had happened. Marcos appeared from the bathroom. After introductions —Marcos staring at Vanesa wide-eyed and Nadia blushing— we sat down to eat.

The conversations were varied, and it wasn’t until the end, once the wine had loosened our tongues, that things got interesting. Lucía told them what had happened while Nadia turned red and Marcos didn’t know where to look.

—The truth is we really enjoyed it —my wife said.

—What a shame we missed it —Vanesa replied, never taking her eyes off Marcos, who at that very moment was looking at her breasts.

Vanesa’s nipples pushed against the thin fabric of her blouse, making it clear she wasn’t wearing a bra either. Lucía, Nadia, and I had fun watching the poor reactions of Marcos. To our surprise, he was far more reserved than his girlfriend, who with every gesture showed us —and she still had plenty left to show— how eager she was to try new things.